Marble (Choc/Butter)- Can't decide on a flavor? Love chocolate and "yellow cake"? Marble is a perfect swirled combination of both!


Peach Bellini- Our popular champagne cake topped with a delicious peach cream cheese frosting!


Butter Pecan- The richest, butteriest, most outstandingly pecan-iest cake we can make!


Chocolate Covered Cherry- Our moist Hershey's chocolate cake topped with smooth cherry buttercream.


Chocolate Brownie Fudge: Chocolate overdose! Worlds collide for a chocolate cake and brownie batter and drizzle of chocolate fudge ganache! Chocolate buttercream is added for Cupcakes & Yum Jars!


Buttered Popcorn- Talk about salty and sweet colliding!


Black Forest- Our moist hershey's chocolate cake, filled with whipped frosting and cherries.


Champagne: A rising new popular flavor- A cake that is super moist and full of champagne flavor! Perfect for New Year’s Eve, Weddings, Engagement Parties or any special occasion!


Pina Colada: Take your taste buds to the beach with this flavor! The Filled with pineapple preserves and frosted with a coconut buttercream and garnished with toasted coconut, a pineapple wedges and a cherry on top!


Lemon Tart: Our fragrant lemon cake frosted with a lemon-vanilla buttercream and topped with a fresh lemon wedges!​

Chocolate Lovers: Our delicious Hershey's chocolate cake topped with our decadent homemade chocolate frosting and drizzled with milk chocolate!

Turtle: Our delicious Hershey's chocolate cake with a caramel-pretzel frosting, drizzled with a sweet caramel sauce and topped with pretzel pieces!

Chocolate Vanilla: ​Our best selling vanilla cake topped with our decadent homemade chocolate frosting!

Birthday Cake: Our best selling vanilla cake topped with delicious buttercream frosting and sprinkles...no party is complete without sprinkles!

Strawberry Sundae:  Our best selling vanilla cake frosted with strawberry milkshake frosting and a milk chocolate ganache. Complete with sprinkles and a cherry on top!

Cherry Limeade: A tart lime cake and frosted with a maraschino cherry buttercream, rimmed with sparkling sugar and a cherry on top!

After Dinner Mint: A mint infused chocolate cake topped with a mint buttercream and Andes mints!

German Choc: Light chocolate cake with classic toasted coconut-pecan frosting!

Italian Cream: A southern, old fashioned staple from Granny's cookbook. Moist, fluffy, and full of buttery-vanilla-coconut-pecan flavor complemented by a pecan and toasted coconut cream cheese frosting. 

Hummingbird: Another Southern tradition, a Banana-Pineapple Spice cake packed full of pecans and frosted in a deliciously nutty cream cheese frosting.

Scarlet(Red Velvet): A chef at New York's Waldorf-Astoria Hotel in the 1920s began serving this devilish red chocolate cake with a cream cheese frosting. Patrons could not get enough of this at the time! So much so that he sold his recipe for $350 (that is about $4,470.96 today). The popularity of our velvety red "Scarlet" is just the same as in 1920! 

Mocha Latte: Our version of a Mocha Latte is a double shot of flavor! A rich and flavorful coffee cake creates the foundation. We spread on a thick layer of Chocolate-Coffee Frosting and drizzle it with caramel and chocolate—and you don't have to wait in the drive-thru for it.


Toasted Coconut: Our take on a Southern tradition. A cake packed with coconut flavor and frosted in a delicious light and airy whipped frosting. Sprinkled with toasted coconut to garnish!

Orange Dreamsicle: A light, flavorful citrus cake with buttercream frosting. Perfect for any summer gathering!

Snickerdoodle: A warm cinnamon graham cake made with cinnamon, vanilla and butter. Frosted with a cinnamon sugar buttercream.

Southern Caramel: A classic yellow cake with decadently rich caramel frosting! Also available in our Thin Layer Cake!

Butterfinger: Our delicious butter cake, packed full of Butterfingers bits and topped with our decadent chocolate frosting and sprinkled with more Butterfingers bits!

Wildberry: A blast of Strawberries and Blueberries combine in this delicious cake, flavored with local honey. Topped with a Honey-Buttercream or Honey-Creamcheese frosting! 

Black+White: Our ever popular Hershey's chocolate cake topped with buttercream frosting and dusted with cocoa powder.

Strawberry: Fresh strawberries take over our vanilla cake and make pink goodness! Topped with Buttercream frosting or, a popular favorite, Strawberry cream cheese frosting!

Oreo: Someone spilled the cookie jar into the mixer! This cake is loaded with Doublestuffed Oreo cookies and frosted with an Oreo cookie buttercream!

Kahlua Cream: A coffee- flavored liqueur cake topped with our delicious chocolate frosting.


Tiramisu: A coffee and rum soaked cake topped with Marsala cream-cheese frosting!


Banana: It is B-A-N-A-N-A-S!


Raspberry: A sweet delicate raspberry flavored cake topped with buttercream frosting.


Key Lime: A zippy & bright key lime flavored cake topped with Key Lime buttercream or Key Lime cream-cheese!


Pumpkin Spice: *Seasonal Flavor*


Peanut Butter: This cake taste like you just grabbed a spoonful out of the jar! Topped with our homemade buttercream frosting!


Fruity Pebble​: Someone spilled the Fruity Pebbles into our cake batter...and we LOVE it! Topped with buttercream frosting.


Almond: Also known as "Wedding Cake". A popular, traditional almond flavored cake. Topped with buttercream frosting.


Blueberry: Our vanilla cake with an explosion of blueberries mixed throughout!


Carrot Cake: Cinnamon, spice and all things nice...like fresh grated carrots and pecans! Topped with pecan cream cheese.


Butter: AKA "Yellow Cake"!


Thin Layer Chocolate (Dessert Cake Only)
Thin Layer Caramel (Dessert Cake Only)
Thin Layer Turtle (Dessert Cake Only)
Sour Cream Pound Cake (Dessert Cake Only)
Cream Cheese Pound Cake (Dessert Cake Only)
Cinnamon Apple Pound Cake (Dessert Cake Only)
Lemon Pound Cake (Dessert Cake Only)

Flavors...51 and growing daily! 

Here is a sample of our flavors. If you do not see what you are looking for, just ask! We can do almost any flavor imaginable!

MaePolly's Cake Co. | 1573 Baytree Rd, Valdosta, Georgia 31602, United States | 12292348437